People of the Book


by Geraldine Brooks
Published by Viking, 2008

Reviewed by Janet Goldwasser
There's a line in a John McCutcheon song: "My stories aren't factual, but they're true." That certainly applies to People of the Book. This is a work of fiction that imagines the history of the Sarajevo Haggadah*. Starting with the 1990s restoration of the beautifully illustrated text, Geraldine Brooks has woven a web of stories going back over the centuries to the Haggadah's origins in 15th century Spain. Onto the skeleton of a few known facts, she has created flesh-and- blood fictionalized characters to bring this remarkable story to life. The Sarajevo Haggadah was created in Seville, around 1480; it survived the expulsion of the Jews from Spain in the 1490s, the Inquisition in Venice in the 1500s, Nazi book-burnings in the 1940s, and the siege of Sarajevo in the 1990s.

Brooks draws you into the book through the character Hanna Heath, a rare-book conservator. She does not "restore" books, she stabilizes them. In her view, the tears, stains, and markings in old books give us valuable information about their history. When Hanna is called to Sarajevo in 1996 to work on the five-hundred-year-old Haggadah, she finds artifacts which lead to minor mysteries: How did an insect wing get crushed between the pages --- a wing from an insect found only in high altitudes? There are wine stains on one page, but when the wine is analyzed it is not kosher wine (and therefore would not have come from a seder service). Where did it come from? Why is this Haggadah so lavishly illustrated when it dates from a time when Jews forbade representational art? Why does its picture of a Jewish seder dinner show an African woman seated among the European family?

We get the answers to these questions in the course of the book. But more important, we get a message: the survival of this remarkable document shows that the "people of the book" --- Jews, Muslims, and Christians --- can respect each other and live peacefully together.

When the SWE CD Book Club (Ann Arbor) discussed the book at our July meeting, we all felt the book's best point was its message. The weakest part was the extensive sub-plot of Hanna's relationship with her snobbish mother. In our opinion, this detracted from the story that Brooks was telling. But this was a minor criticism, and we all recommend the book.

*A Haggadah is the text for the Jewish Passover seder which tells the story of the flight of the Jews from oppression in Egypt in the time of the Pharaohs.


4.5 stars out of 5


Return to the book club page.